Who is online?
In total there are 2 users online :: 0 Registered, 0 Hidden and 2 Guests :: 1 BotNone
Most users ever online was 112 on 8th October 2020, 7:09 am
Latest topics
» Hungry Birdsby Dirick55 7th December 2023, 6:04 am
» PRESENTATION
by Chilli-head 23rd November 2023, 2:55 pm
» New Kiva loan
by Chilli-head 21st July 2023, 12:35 pm
» A peat-free compost is top in UK Which? magazine trial
by Dandelion 25th April 2023, 9:42 pm
» New gardening year 2023
by Chilli-head 5th March 2023, 10:15 pm
» What have I done in the workshop today?
by Dandelion 2nd December 2022, 1:12 pm
» What are you harvesting today?
by Dandelion 2nd December 2022, 1:12 pm
» Wartime marrow casserole
by Dandelion 18th October 2022, 4:42 pm
» Late sowings in August ... beans ?
by Ploshkin 11th August 2022, 9:29 am
» Come August, come night in the garden
by Chilli-head 4th August 2022, 3:29 pm
» Welcome guest
by Ploshkin 31st July 2022, 9:16 am
» The Jolly July Garden
by Ploshkin 19th July 2022, 11:38 am
» More mead ...
by Chilli-head 13th July 2022, 12:52 pm
» The June garden thread
by Dandelion 25th June 2022, 9:55 pm
» Plastic bags
by Dandelion 5th June 2022, 7:28 pm
» The merry May garden
by Dandelion 31st May 2022, 10:04 pm
» Fooling around in the April garden
by freebird 1st May 2022, 8:33 am
» March into the garden
by Dandelion 1st April 2022, 7:26 pm
» Mow Suggestions
by freebird 29th March 2022, 5:48 pm
» Some thoughts on resilience
by Ploshkin 12th March 2022, 2:23 pm
Statistics
We have 270 registered usersThe newest registered user is Lloyd
Our users have posted a total of 48045 messages in 2416 subjects
Similar topics
Size matters?
+2
Compostwoman
Hairyloon
6 posters
Page 1 of 1
Size matters?
I have been looking a bit at wind turbines, and I am a bit puzzled. It seems that bigger turbines cost more than small ones. :?
OK, you would expect that, but the difference is far more than I would expect: I was just looking at a site, and a 10kW turbine is around four times the price of a 5kW turbine from the same manufacturer.
Why not have four 5kW for the same price, or two 5kW for the same power?
What am I missing? (OK, yes, inverters. Revise the figures to three times, not four).
OK, you would expect that, but the difference is far more than I would expect: I was just looking at a site, and a 10kW turbine is around four times the price of a 5kW turbine from the same manufacturer.
Why not have four 5kW for the same price, or two 5kW for the same power?
What am I missing? (OK, yes, inverters. Revise the figures to three times, not four).
Hairyloon- Posts : 649
Join date : 2009-12-09
Location : UK
Re: Size matters?
Much higher safety issues with bigger ones, so welding, materials etc etc have to be much more stringent and stuff has to be checked even more.
was my first thought.
was my first thought.
Compostwoman- Posts : 5688
Join date : 2009-11-08
Re: Size matters?
Certainly there may be good reasons why they cost more, but where is the sense in having few big instead of lots of little ones?
There appear to be lots of advantages to little ones, and the only one I can see for the big ones is that they get more wind because theyre higher up.
There appear to be lots of advantages to little ones, and the only one I can see for the big ones is that they get more wind because theyre higher up.
Hairyloon- Posts : 649
Join date : 2009-12-09
Location : UK
Re: Size matters?
Will return to the likely cost issues later but will answer the second question first.
Another topic in this section -- killing birds. Four 5 kw turbines will kill more birds than one 20 kw (one twice the diameter). Same swept area and so same chance that a bird passes through that swept area but the probability that a bird passing through gets hit by a blade is different.
OK, back to cost. Can be a number of reasons.
a) Apples and oranges? May not be talking about anything like the same design and capabilities. The really large turbines are "feathering". Are the little ones with which you are comparing doing that?
b) At what "wind domain" are the ratings you are comapring? The same? This can be related to "a".
Note the obvious. If it were realy true that 100 kw being produced by a hundred 1 kw turbines would be cheaper than one 100 kw turbine why do you see the "wind farms" using big turbines rather than large numbers of small ones.
Another topic in this section -- killing birds. Four 5 kw turbines will kill more birds than one 20 kw (one twice the diameter). Same swept area and so same chance that a bird passes through that swept area but the probability that a bird passing through gets hit by a blade is different.
OK, back to cost. Can be a number of reasons.
a) Apples and oranges? May not be talking about anything like the same design and capabilities. The really large turbines are "feathering". Are the little ones with which you are comparing doing that?
b) At what "wind domain" are the ratings you are comapring? The same? This can be related to "a".
Note the obvious. If it were realy true that 100 kw being produced by a hundred 1 kw turbines would be cheaper than one 100 kw turbine why do you see the "wind farms" using big turbines rather than large numbers of small ones.
Mike- Posts : 484
Join date : 2009-11-08
Age : 79
Location : Step by Step Farm, Berkshire Mtns, Massachusetts, USA
Re: Size matters?
Is that theory, or based on evidence? I am still puzzled why birds choose that bit of sky to fly through.Mike wrote:Another topic in this section -- killing birds. Four 5 kw turbines will kill more birds than one 20 kw (one twice the diameter). Same swept area and so same chance that a bird passes through that swept area but the probability that a bird passing through gets hit by a blade is different.
Anyway, is that really a disadvantage? Can always make pies.
No, for the ones I was looking at, the smaller ones cut in at a lower wind speed... In many situations, that might be considered another point in their favour.b) At what "wind domain" are the ratings you are comapring? The same? This can be related to "a".
How long have you known me now?Note the obvious. If it were realy true that 100 kw being produced by a hundred 1 kw turbines would be cheaper than one 100 kw turbine why do you see the "wind farms" using big turbines rather than large numbers of small ones.
You must realise by now that I'll never accept the obvious answer as right, just because it is obvious (unless it is obviously right, obviously).
There are plenty of reasons why the obvious answer may be wrong; politics, profit margins, quirks in the planning law. Plus I've not actually looked at the price of a really big turbine, they might come back the other way.
Hairyloon- Posts : 649
Join date : 2009-12-09
Location : UK
Re: Size matters?
Which relates to my theory as to everybody that can having the option for solar power as opposed to several big nuclear plants...
Surely "lots of littles" would have less impact than "several bigs"...
Although the one flaw I do see in that theory would be if we were all offered our own little nuclear plant, perhaps a "nuclear seedling", to have a mini nuclear reactor on every street corner & make the whole country radioactive would probably count as not good...
Surely "lots of littles" would have less impact than "several bigs"...
Although the one flaw I do see in that theory would be if we were all offered our own little nuclear plant, perhaps a "nuclear seedling", to have a mini nuclear reactor on every street corner & make the whole country radioactive would probably count as not good...
Sparhawk- Posts : 1787
Join date : 2009-11-15
Age : 56
Location : Isle of Wight
Re: Size matters?
sparhawk wrote:
Although the one flaw I do see in that theory would be if we were all offered our own little nuclear plant, perhaps a "nuclear seedling", to have a mini nuclear reactor on every street corner & make the whole country radioactive would probably count as not good...
Actually quite the reverse. On idea being put forward is for tiny nuclear reactors on a neighbourhood scale, which are actually quite a sensible idea.
Re: Size matters?
I am game.
However, I think that arguing the case on those that a DIY install should be eligible for FITs is a job I will leave for someone else.
However, I think that arguing the case on those that a DIY install should be eligible for FITs is a job I will leave for someone else.
Hairyloon- Posts : 649
Join date : 2009-12-09
Location : UK
Re: Size matters?
Hairyloon wrote:
Is that theory, or based on evidence? I am still puzzled why birds choose that bit of sky to fly through.
Need to step back a moment. There are two ways in which "theory" is used in science and one of these is directly related to being able to do meaningful experiments/observations. In other words, if these "theories" do not hold, then observations aren't a valid way to proceed either.
I am tallking about "beliefs" such as "if there is no difference between two situations then our observations of them will be the same" (and experiments are repeatable, etc.)
A consequence of that is that is if we can determine that there is no difference between two situations then we do not actually conduct the experiment to see that the results are the same. If that were not true, then conducting the experiment would not be useful either.
Yes of course I was making assumptions. But those were things like there being no difference in the placing of the turbines relative to the usual flight paths of birds. And things like the tip speed to wind speed ratio being the same in both the large and small (blades equally visible/invisible to birds according to their ability to see and judge the path of things moving at that speed).
Change your question to the other way around. Why would the birds not choose to fly through that bit of space compared to some other bit of space. What is the difference you claim?
Mike- Posts : 484
Join date : 2009-11-08
Age : 79
Location : Step by Step Farm, Berkshire Mtns, Massachusetts, USA
Re: Size matters?
I'm just thinking statistically: there is a heck of a lot of sky without turbines in it, and only a small amount with.
From the fuss made, that small amount seems to kill a disproportionate amount of birds.
From the fuss made, that small amount seems to kill a disproportionate amount of birds.
Hairyloon- Posts : 649
Join date : 2009-12-09
Location : UK
Re: Size matters?
I have been following this thread and it appears that only the men have been bantering back and forth on the matter with the question still unanswered.....
I would like to think that if any of the women of the forum were to put their opinion forth....we would surely agree that....yes....size does matter!
I know....it is.... , but I can't help myself!
I would like to think that if any of the women of the forum were to put their opinion forth....we would surely agree that....yes....size does matter!
I know....it is.... , but I can't help myself!
Re: Size matters?
So do you prefer one great big one, or two small energetic ones? :?Lizbuff13 wrote:I would like to think that if any of the women of the forum were to put their opinion forth....we would surely agree that....yes....size does matter!
Hairyloon- Posts : 649
Join date : 2009-12-09
Location : UK
Re: Size matters?
Lizbuff13 wrote: if any of the women of the forum were to put their opinion forth
like that would ever happen
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|